Big Spread at Tickmill, Is it Safe?

Broker review
D
Deddy
14 Mar 2020, 09:05 2,411 Views

Is it safe to play with a large amount of money in Tickmill, and what's the difference in SC regulation, because Indonesian traders must be registered with SC Tickmill?

7 Answer

R
rizki rosadi 21 Mar 2020, 22:09

@Deddy: I think it's less safe for large funds because the regulations from SC (Seychelles) are less guaranteed. Seychelles is an island nation located in East Africa.

There is safer regulation from Tickmill, namely FCA UK, but Tickmill UK regulated under FCA UK cannot accept clients from outside the UK. Apart from UK citizens, they will be directed to tickmill seychelles.

It is better to choose a broker regulated by an internationally credible regulatory body, namely: CFTC, NFA, FCA, FSA, FINMA, MiFID, ASIC and FMA.

For reference, you can visit the following broker pages:

D
deddy 17 May 2020, 20:03
yes, the recommendations you gave below are on par with tickmill, and some are even below tickmill.
R
rizki rosadi 21 May 2020, 06:20
@deddy: Here are some recommended brokers with good regulation, for example Saxobank, Dukascopy, FXCM, Oanda, Swissquote, Forex.com, City Index, IG, ICmarkets, Vantage FX.
J
Jaka Sembung 25 May 2020, 10:38
@Master Rizki
Do the brokers you mentioned accept clients from Indonesia?
Of those brokers, which one is the best based on your experience?
J
Jaka Sembung 25 May 2020, 10:45
My master is a bit confused about the broker regulation system. Indeed, it's good if a broker is regulated by the FCA, but when clients from Indonesia register, they are directed to offshore broker regulations? It's the same as getting an unreliable broker. Even though the broker is credible in England, when the client comes from Indonesia, the broker becomes unreliable.
R
rizki rosadi 27 May 2020, 06:36

@Jaka Sembung: do the brokers you mentioned accept clients from Indonesia?

All forex brokers above accept clients from Indonesia.

.... out of those brokers, which broker is the best according to your experience?

Interactive Brokers first, Saxobank runner-up.

indeed that broker is well regulated by the FCA but when clients from Indonesia register they are directed with offshore broker regulation?

This is a challenge that many Indonesian traders who are already consistently profitable and want to grow their accounts face. Many brokers write credible regulations but when Indonesian traders register, they are directed to offshore regulations. That is why I clearly wrote the brokers above, because some of them do not redirect to offshore regulations. Interactive Brokers, Saxobank, Oanda, City Index, Swissquote do not redirect to offshore regulations if Indonesian traders register with them.

R
ronalS 14 Apr 2021, 05:51
@Deddy, it seems safe to use large funds at Tickmill. I once saw a deposit list at one of the Indonesian IBs where someone deposited $100,000. In Malaysia, traders also like Tickmill and if you open Tickmill PRIME, it's specifically for hedge fund & IT traders / large capital traders. Personally, I still trade at Tickmill with only a few thousand dollars, hopefully this helps.

Add Answer

Loading editor...
Back to Forum

Forum Tickmill

view all

Testimonials Tickmill

view all